Which is the best insurance for car? Top 10 Auto Insurance Agencies in US with A Complete Guide

best insurance for car

Today there are over 6,000 different auto insurance agencies for the best insurance for car. This makes it hard to choose the right auto coverage for you. Other drivers could be searching for the best affordable automobile insurance. Some others may be seeking strong customer service or a simple claim submission process. It doesn’t really matter what you prefer, it won’t be easy to find the right company.

This switch rate shows that people are returning to old patterns after the Covid-19 crisis. Auto insurance shopping was booming at the start of the pandemic. More than 45% of auto customers shopped for new automobile insurance policies, decreased coverage, switched companies, or even dropped their policies.

How to Choose The Best Auto Insurance Agencies

A few guidelines can help you find the best price and coverage when you buy auto insurance.

Go searching:

Compare quotes from different insurers. They may offer you the opportunity to match coverages, discounts and optional coverages.

Inquire about discounts:

For additional savings, most insurance companies offer discounts you can qualify for. Ask potential insurance agents which insurers might help you to lower your premium.

Consider your coverage needs:

Your coverage options can vary depending on how much you’re able to afford, what vehicle value you have, whether your vehicle is financed, and other factors.

Bundle your policies:

Many carriers offer discounts to policyholders purchasing multiple types of insurance.

Review financial strength ratings:

With companies such as Standard & Poor’s and Moody’s you can verify an insurer’s financial strength rating. A coffee rating could mean that a corporation may not be ready to pay claims if it is inundated.

Research customer service reviews:

J.D. Power publishes research that ranks insurance companies on customer satisfaction, claims service satisfaction, overall customer experience and overall customer satisfaction. Although finding the best auto insurance agencies can be time-consuming, it is often worth the effort.

Factors That Impact the value of Auto Insurance

There are several factors that will affect the price of your car insurance.

Your driving records

Your driving experience as well as your age

Wherever you are

Choices in coverage

You can deduct a portion of your collision and comprehensive coverage.

Vehicle model

Your car insurance history

Credit-based insurance score (use it in automobile insurance costs is illegal in California Hawaii Massachusetts and Michigan)

Auto Insurance Agencies Basic Charges

For good drivers

$1,556

For drivers who have caused an accident with property damage

$1,732

For drivers who have caused an accident that injured someone else

$2,541

For drivers who have caused an accident that injured someone else

$1,732

For drivers with a DUI conviction

$2,595

For drivers who have poor credit

$2,860

For drivers who were caught without insurance

$1,764

What are the Top 10 Auto Insurance Agencies which are in the US 2021? best insurance for car in 2022.

There are many insurance companies that offer auto insurance in the US. Bankrate’s insurance editorial team reviewed each company’s average minimum or full coverage premiums. This included coverages, discounts as well financial strength scores. With this information, each company was assigned a Bankrate Rating. The scores are from 5.0. Higher scores indicate that a corporation has been ranked higher in each scoring category. The following is a list displaying the top 10 US-based auto insurance providers in 2021.State Farm: 16.19%

State Farm: 16.19%

Geico: 13.54%

Progressive: 13.30%

Allstate: 9.11%

USAA: 6.32%

Liberty Mutual: 4.75%

Farmers Insurance: 3.98%

Nationwide: 2.32%

American Family: 2.07%

Travelers: 1.96%

So how do these auto insurance agencies compare? Each has its advantages, and therefore the best company for one person might not be the simplest for an additional.

1. State Farm

State Farm is America’s largest private insurer for autos. State Farm agents have access to insurance, bank products, and loans. State Farm may be worth your consideration if you’re in the market for insurance and banking services. J.D. Power are mostly average.  Customers are usually satisfied with State Farm’s response to claims in the event that they occur.

Standout feature

State Farm’s 19,000 independent contractor agents, and 58,000 employees make it easy to search for help in your particular area.

  • Headquarters: Bloomington, Illinois
  • Market share percentage: 16.19%
  • Average annual full coverage rate: $1,457
  • Average annual min coverage rate: $539
  • Bankrate Score: 4.4

Read also: Best Flood Insurance Companies

2. Geico

Geico is one among the most popular auto insurance companies in America and covers nearly 28,000,000 vehicles. Geico Gecko ads are a great way to remember its slogan, “15 minutes could stop 15% or more automobile insurance.” J.D. Power rated Geico as a top customer satisfaction provider. Power is impressive. It won first place in customer service satisfaction within the Northwest Central, Southwest, and North Central regions. This shows customers are satisfied with Geico’s customer service.

  • Headquarters: Chevy Chase, Maryland
  • Market share percentage: 13.54%
  • Average annual full coverage rate: $1,405
  • Average annual min coverage rate: $433
  • Bankrate Score: 4.6

Read also: What is Car Insurance? Benefits Auto Insurance

3. Progressive

The third-largest U.S. insurer, Progressive, offers a variety of coverage options to protect your vehicle, home and boats. Progressive’s revolutionary trace program can save you a lot of money. This innovative program tracks you’re driving in real time and offers safety driving discounts. Progressive’s customer satisfaction rating J.D. Progressive’s Power ratings are generally average. It also received a lower-than average ranking for claims services.

  • Headquarters: Mayfield Village, Ohio
  • Market share percentage: 13.30%
  • Average annual full coverage rate: $1,509
  • Average annual min coverage rate: $582
  • Bankrate Score: 4.1

4. Allstate

Allstate makes it easy for you to bundle multiple insurance types. J.D. rates Allstate customer satisfaction. Power can vary depending upon where you are in the U.S. Allstate offers a free quote, but you should read the reviews from your specific region.

Allstate Standout feature

Allstate’s usage-based Drive wise program provides a 40 percent discount for those who drive well. Participating in Drive wise programs can also earn rewards point, which they can redeem to buy car rentals, magazine subscriptions or gift cards.

  • Headquarters: Northbrook, Illinois
  • Market share percentage: 9.11%
  • Average annual full coverage rate: $1,921
  • Average annual min coverage rate: $696
  • Bankrate Score: 3.6

5. USAA

USAA is an insurance company that provides insurance to military families. They offer heavily discounted auto insurance policies to servicemembers with an average annual savings $725. USAA ranks fifth in the US as an auto insurance provider. J.D. consistently gives USAA high customer satisfaction scores. Power, although the corporate is not eligible for an official ranking due its eligibility restrictions.

USAA Standout feature

USAA offers vehicle storage and flexible payment options for military personnel currently deployed.

  • Headquarters: San Antonio , Texas
  • Market share percentage: 6.32%
  • Average annual full coverage rate: $1,225
  • Average annual min coverage rate: $384
  • Bankrate Score: 4.8

6. Liberty Mutual

Liberty Mutual insurance can be purchased for anything you need, from pet insurance to home insurance. The company’s auto policy is simple to access and easy to bundle with other policies. Bundling does not guarantee savings. Liberty Mutual lists 17 discounts that customers can take to get the best deal on their automobile insurance. Liberty Mutual has a J.D. These Power customer satisfaction scores can vary depending on the region. When you receive a quote from this company, you should investigate customer satisfaction in that area.

Liberty Mutual Standout feature

Liberty Mutual’s Better Car Replacement plan will replace your car with a one-year-old model with as little as 15,000.

  • Headquarters: Boston, Massachusetts
  • Market share percentage: 4.75%
  • Bankrate Score: 3.9

7. Farmers Insurance Group

Farmers, America’s 7th largest auto insurer, has a broad range of innovative features. If you are a driver for Uber or Lyft companies, you will be able to purchase ridesharing insurance. OEM coverage will also be available. This can help you source original manufacturer parts for your vehicle, if it is damaged. J.D.’s Farmers Survey rated farmers above average for satisfaction in claims. Power. MetLife insurance policyholders may see changes to their branding. There may also be new discounts or coverage options available.

Farmers Insurance Group Standout feature

Farmers’ New Car Replacement Coverage can be a good choice if you’ve recently purchased a replacement automobile. This optional coverage covers the cost of replacing your totaled car by a newer model, provided your vehicle is less than 24,000 miles and not older than 2 years.

  • Headquarters: l. a. , California
  • Market share percentage: 3.98%
  • Average annual full coverage rate: $2,000
  • Average annual min coverage rate: $808
  • Bankrate Score: 3.8

8. Nationwide

Nationwide offers both business and personal insurance. Nationwide provides all the essentials as well as optional coverages including towing, rental cars coverage and gap insurance. This coverage covers the difference in your vehicle’s value and your loan amount if your vehicle is damaged. Nationwide’s J.D.

Nationwide Standout feature

Nationwide could offer $100 off your annual deductible for safe driving. This is up to a maximum limit of $500. This might be enough to cover your entire deductible depending on your policy.

  • Headquarters: Columbus, Ohio
  • Market share percentage: 2.32%
  • Average annual full coverage rate: $1,485
  • Average annual min coverage rate: $501
  • Bankrate Score: 4.3

9. American Family

American Family, more commonly known as Am Fam is a company that sells insurance, including travel, auto, home life, health and travel. This company places emphasis on convenience, offering smartphone apps with features such easy bill pay and a teenage Safe Driver program.

American Family Standout feature

American Family’s Dreams Restored Program eases the burden of finding a partner shop. You do not need to view bills, as they are sent to insurance companies. American Family will also guarantee the workmanship for life.

  • Headquarters: Madison, Wisconsin
  • Market share percentage: 2.07%
  • Average annual full coverage rate: $1,911
  • Average annual min coverage rate: $918
  • Bankrate Score: 3.7

10. Travelers

Travelers provides standard insurance coverages for auto, but also offers options to customize your policy like rental cars, new car replacement or accident forgiveness. There are discounts and savings available through the company that could help you save significant on your policy. Multi-policy discounts, for instance, can save you as much as 13% on your automobile premiums. J.D. rates travelers as having below-average service ratings in claims. Power and lower-than-average customer service satisfaction scores in specific regions.

Travelers Standout feature

Drivers in some states are eligible for IntelliTrace. This smartphone app tracks driving habits for 90-days and reduces your premium. However, your premium will rise if you have unsafe driving habits.

  • Headquarters: ny City, New York
  • Market share percentage: 1.96%
  • Average annual full coverage rate: $1,325
  • Average annual min coverage rate: $469
  • Bankrate Score: 4.5
Scroll to Top